Fun fact: Jesse co-wrote the Leona Lewis megahit “Bleeding Love” with Ryan Tedder. He was in a boyband called Dream Street and played a surfer in the TV show Summerland. Internet Consensus: Turtle is pop singer/actor Jesse McCartney. Robin guesses Joey McIntyre, while Nicole thinks it may be an actor who can sing like Zac Efron. Ken jumps up to say it’s Jenny’s husband Donny and she instantly goes in for the strangle. Ken calls him a “frontrunner.” Jenny thinks it’s somebody she and her husband knows, because he’s cooking a hamburger? And Wahlburgers? That’s a stretch. Seems like a thing a boy bander would do. Jamie yells “Boy Band.” Maybe! He finished with a lovely flourish, handing a rose to an audience member.

Performance: Turtle sings Kiss from a Rose by Seal.